Kayla Treanor is a name that echoes through the lacrosse world like few others. As a player, she was unstoppable—a four-time All-American at Syracuse, a Tewaaraton Award finalist, and one of the most dominant attackers the game has ever seen. As a coach, she’s already cemented her legacy, leading Syracuse to multiple championship games and now taking the reins at Penn State. But behind the highlight reels and trophy ceremonies, there’s a personal story that hasn’t been fully told—her marriage, separation, and the quiet resilience that defines her off the field.
Treanor married Clayton Cleveland, but the details of her relationship with her husband were always kept private. Unlike some athletes who share every milestone on social media, Kayla has always been fiercely protective of her personal life. There were no flashy engagement announcements, no wedding photos splashed across magazines—just a steady, under-the-radar partnership. That’s why when court documents revealed their divorce filing in Saratoga County, New York, it came as a surprise to many fans. The case, Kayla Treanor v. Clayton Cleveland, was finalized in December 2024, but the journey there was anything but simple.
The legal timeline tells its own story. A separation agreement was filed in November 2024, suggesting that the decision to part ways wasn’t sudden. By late October, proposed findings of fact and a judgment of divorce were already in motion, meaning negotiations had been happening behind the scenes for a while.
The fact that the case was categorized as a family matter hints at possible discussions around assets, support, or even children—though there’s no public confirmation that kids were involved. What we do know is that by the end of 2024, the chapter was officially closed. Judge Dianne N. Freestone signed off, and just like that, a relationship that had once been a quiet cornerstone of Kayla’s life was over.
The Aftermath: Moving Forward Without Looking Back
If you expected drama, you won’t find it here. Kayla Treanor isn’t the type to air grievances or fuel speculation. In the months following the divorce, she didn’t post cryptic quotes or give interviews about heartbreak. Instead, she did what she’s always done—threw herself into lacrosse. By May 2025, she was announced as the new head coach at Penn State, a massive career move that signaled not just a fresh start professionally, but personally, too.
At the helm 🤝
Welcome to Happy Valley, Coach Treanor!
📰: https://t.co/XSFnBPn9pO#WeAre pic.twitter.com/V2vjzCFasu
— Penn State Women’s Lacrosse (@PennStateWLAX) May 21, 2025
That’s the thing about Kayla—she’s always been defined by her ability to focus forward. Even during what must have been an emotionally taxing period, she led Syracuse to another competitive season, proving that her personal life wouldn’t derail her professional excellence. And while some might wonder if her personal life affected her coaching, there’s no evidence of that. If anything, her ability to compartmentalize speaks to the same discipline that made her such a lethal player.
You Might Like: Jamey Johnson’s Wife Brittney Eakins: Age, Wedding & His Daughters
Family has always been a grounding force for Treanor. Her father, Mark, was a legendary high school basketball coach, and her sister, Alyssa, is now a head coach herself at Union College. That tight-knit, sports-centric upbringing likely gave her the tools to handle adversity with quiet strength. It’s also why, even in the middle of a divorce, she never lost sight of who she was—a competitor, a leader, and someone who refuses to let personal setbacks define her.
The Bigger Picture: What’s Next for Kayla Treanor?
She said YES💍! Syracuse @CuseWLAX head coach Kayla Treanor is engaged. pic.twitter.com/8vOlNZpotw
— Alex Sims (@AlexSimsTV) August 8, 2022
Now at Penn State, Kayla has a chance to build something new—both for the program and herself. Parting ways is never easy, but if there’s anyone who can turn a period of change into a catalyst for growth, it’s her. She’s already one of the brightest minds in lacrosse, and with a fresh start in Happy Valley, the next era of her career (and life) could be her most exciting yet.
As for love? She’s kept that part of her life completely under wraps. Maybe there’s someone new, maybe she’s taking time for herself—either way, she’s handling it the same way she handles everything else: on her own terms. And that’s the real story here. Kayla Treanor’s legacy isn’t just about wins and losses. It’s about resilience, privacy, and the unshakable focus that turns great athletes into unforgettable icons.
Also See: Phil Robertson’s Family: Meet His Wife Kay and Their Four Children (in Order)
So while the divorce papers are signed and the legal process is over, one thing’s for sure: Kayla Treanor’s story is far from finished. And if history tells us anything, the next chapter will be worth watching.
