Sophie Cunningham isn’t just a powerhouse on the basketball court, she’s also become a magnet for curiosity when it comes to her personal life. The Indiana Fever guard has a knack for keeping fans guessing, whether she’s dropping cheeky TikToks about her single status or shutting down wild rumors with the same fiery energy she brings to the game.
So, let’s break it all down: Is Sophie Cunningham married? Does she have a boyfriend? And what’s the deal with those recent scandalous allegations? Buckle up, because this story’s got layers.
Single, Sassy, and Loving It (Mostly)
If you’ve been following Sophie Cunningham on social media, you already know she’s mastered the art of keeping it real. Earlier this year, she posted a TikTok after a preseason game with a caption that sent fans into a frenzy: “Lol but like I wouldn’t mind a man to take care of me too ya know? 🤣🤣🤣 #fyp.” She doubled down on the sentiment in an Instagram story, reposting the video with the caption, “lol we still want and need the boy too.” Clearly, Cunningham isn’t afraid to admit she’s single, and maybe even a little amused by how much people care about it.
You Might Like: Tyler Perry’s Staggering $1.4 Billion Net Worth in 2025
But why is she single? When a fan bluntly asked her about it, she responded with a hilarious video of herself chugging a drink at the WNBA All-Star Game, joking, “I think it’s cause I’m a rat and an embarrassment to society.” She followed up with, “But back to being not married, it’ll happen hopefully before I die CAUSE WON’T HE DO IT.” Classic Sophie—equal parts self-deprecating and unapologetically confident.
That said, she hasn’t always flown solo. Back in 2019, she was publicly linked to Jakob Neidig, a former dual-sport athlete (football and basketball) from her alma mater, the University of Missouri. The two were spotted together at games, and Neidig even rocked her jersey in support. But by May 2020, the relationship seemed to fizzle out, with no further social media hints of romance. Since then, Cunningham’s kept her dating life under wraps, focusing instead on hoops, her dog Brutus, and her signature “sporty but edgy” fashion sense.
Rumors, Lawsuits, and Denials: The Messy Side of Fame
Just when it seemed like Cunningham’s love life couldn’t get more headline-worthy, a bombshell lawsuit dropped in May 2025. A former Phoenix Suns employee, Gene Traylor, claimed in legal documents that the Suns’ VP of security had been spreading rumors about Cunningham having an affair with married CEO Josh Bartelstein. The allegation was explosive—Bartelstein, who’s been married to his wife Sydney since 2022, was accused of being involved with Cunningham while she was still playing for the Mercury.
The lawsuit, which centered on workplace discrimination and retaliation, didn’t hold back. Traylor alleged that he warned Bartelstein about the rumors, even quoting the VP as saying, “Josh Bartelstein is f–king Sophie Cunningham.” The Suns immediately shut it down, calling the claims “entirely false and morally reprehensible” and slamming Traylor’s lawyer for what they called a pattern of “salacious lies.”
Cunningham, meanwhile, took to X (formerly Twitter) to fire back: “I am deeply saddened by the recent false accusations made against me by Gene Traylor, someone I do not know and have never met.” She called the claims “untrue and extremely hurtful,” emphasizing that her focus was on basketball, not drama.
— Sophie Cunningham (@sophaller) May 21, 2025
So, where does that leave us? For now, Cunningham’s love life remains a mix of open-book honesty (see: her TikTok antics) and fiercely guarded privacy (see: her refusal to entertain gossip). She’s made it clear she’s not married (no husband or wife), not currently dating (no boyfriend or girlfriend), and definitely not sneaking around with any married CEOs. Moreover, there’s no confirmation if she’s gay or has a mystery partner despite fan speculations. In all likelihood, she’s single. And honestly? That’s probably how she likes it—free to focus on ball, her fans, and maybe, just maybe, finding that elusive “man to take care of her” when the time’s right.
Also See: Tyler Perry’s Sexuality: Is He Gay, Straight or Bisexual?
Final Thoughts: Sophie’s Love Life, On Her Terms
At the end of the day, Sophie Cunningham’s relationship status is nobody’s business but hers. She’s cracked jokes about being single, shut down false rumors with grace, and kept her past relationships relatively low-key. Whether she’s dropping 20-point games for the Fever or clapping back at tabloid nonsense, one thing’s for sure: She’s doing it her way. And if history’s any indication, whenever she does decide to let someone into her life, you can bet she’ll announce it with the same unfiltered charm that’s made her a fan favorite—no lawsuits required.
