Sandy Gallagher quickly became a fan favorite in Season 3 of Netflix’s ‘The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On,’ a show where couples decide whether to tie the knot or call it quits—while also exploring connections with other cast members.
At 29, Sandy brought plenty of charm and a perfectly polished vibe to the screen. Off-camera, she’s a lifestyle content creator on TikTok, sharing bits of her life, including travel, food, and fashion, with her small but loyal fanbase. But her time on ‘The Ultimatum’ didn’t just put her love life in the spotlight—it also sparked plenty of discussions about her possible cosmetic enhancements.
From surgical tweaks to non-surgical touch-ups, Sandy’s transformation has stirred up some heated debates among fans online, with people chiming in on both sides.
How Did Sandy Gallagher From ‘The Ultimatum’ Look Before Plastic Surgery?
A major point of speculation about Sandy’s appearance revolves around her nose, which several ‘The Ultimatum’ viewers reckon looked “cute” before. Many fans and commenters believe Sandy underwent a rhinoplasty procedure sometime between 2018 and her appearance on the show. Observers have pointed out that her nose now appears more narrow and defined, contrasting with earlier photos where it had a softer, more natural contour.
This change after surgery, while aligning with modern beauty ideals, has elicited polarized reactions. Some believe the nose job was unnecessary and disrupted the harmony of her facial features. “That is a nose job nose 10000%,” a fan remarked during an online discussion on Reddit, with others agreeing that the procedure makes her face look less balanced. Comparisons were even drawn between her appearance and that of other reality TV stars who have similarly adopted sharp, sculpted features.
Her lips have also become a focal point of attention. Many assert that Sandy has received lip fillers to achieve a fuller, plumper look. The impact of this procedure has been both praised and criticized. While fuller lips are a trend embraced by many celebrities and influencers, some fans noted that her altered lips affect the way she speaks and smiles.
“She doesn’t look like she has top teeth anymore,” one commenter noted, attributing this to the excess volume in her upper lip. Others have remarked that her lips give the impression of perpetual puckering, which they find distracting, especially during her more emotional moments on-screen.
Botox treatments are another alleged component of Sandy’s transformation. Speculation suggests she has used Botox to smooth out fine lines and maintain a youthful complexion. While Botox can create a polished look, some fans argue that it has left her face looking overly frozen or lacking in natural expression. “Her face just doesn’t move the same,” someone pointed out in a thread dissecting her appearance.
Critics of this change argue that the lack of expressiveness makes her come across as less relatable and more like an Instagram-filtered version of herself, further amplifying the “uncanny valley” effect that some say makes her hard to watch.
The changes Sandy’s made have stirred up a lot of debate about how cosmetic procedures have affected her look. Some people think the transformation has made her look older, with many surprised to find out she was just 27 during filming. “I thought she was in her late 30s or early 40s,” one fan admitted, echoing what a lot of others are saying online.
There are also plenty of comparisons floating around between her current look and pre-surgery photos from her college days at Penn State. Back then, Sandy had a softer, more natural appearance that many commenters are calling “pretty” and “natural.” One fan even put together a gallery of her old pictures, captioning it, “She looked so much better before all the work.”
Beyond the major changes to her nose, lips, and overall facial structure, there is speculation about other minor tweaks. Some viewers have suggested that she may have had jawline contouring or subtle tweaks to enhance the symmetry of her face. Others noted her reliance on hair extensions, which complement her polished image but contribute to the perception of an artificial aesthetic. The stark contrast between her polished look now and her earlier photos has led some to label her transformation as part of a broader trend among influencers and reality TV stars to conform to rigid beauty standards.
Interestingly, not all feedback has been critical. There are those who admire Sandy’s commitment to presenting herself in a way that aligns with her personal ideals. Supporters argue that beauty is subjective and that Sandy’s choice to undergo these procedures should be respected if they boost her confidence. Others have speculated that her transformations might be linked to her time in the spotlight, with the pressures of being a reality TV star magnifying insecurities and encouraging cosmetic enhancements.
What makes Sandy’s story so polarizing is that it mirrors larger societal conversations about the influence of social media and reality television on beauty standards. For many viewers, her transformation exemplifies the pressures young women face in environments that reward a specific, often unattainable, aesthetic. These platforms amplify the idea of the “Instagram face,” which Sandy now embodies: high cheekbones, full lips, a sharp nose, and a wrinkle-free complexion. While this look is admired by some, others argue that it erases individuality and authenticity.
